We’ve Been Treating Addiction Backwards: A Conversation with Dee-Dee Stout
AHRT founding member Dee-Dee Stout, MA, recently joined Kirsten Johnson on her podcast for a conversation about harm reduction, moderation, and why so much addiction treatment asks people to do the hardest thing first. Dee-Dee has worked in addiction and mental health for nearly 40 years. She is a member of the Motivational Interviewing Network of Trainers, has led more than 1,000 trainings, and wrote Coming to Harm Reduction Kicking and Screaming.
Watch the full episode below, or read on for some of the ideas that stood out to us.
We’ve Been Treating Addiction Backwards
CAHRT member Dee-Dee Stout, MA, joins Kirsten Johnson to talk about why traditional addiction treatment so often gets it backwards, and what a harm reduction approach looks like instead.
Asking people to give up their coping tool first
Early in her career, Dee-Dee studied relapse prevention and came to know G. Alan Marlatt, one of the researchers who shaped harm reduction. She recalls him telling her, “the problem is that we ask people to give up their coping mechanism before we help them to learn something to replace it.”
That is how most treatment works, she says, and then “we wonder why it fails, why people fail. No, treatment failed.”
She also credits Patt Denning with a point that changed how she saw the field. We don’t ask people with depression to stop being depressed before they can get treatment, yet with substance use we ask people to give up the very thing they’re seeking help for. That idea sits at the heart of harm reduction therapy.
Leaving the door open
For years, Dee-Dee’s office policy said clients could not come to sessions under the influence. About 25 years ago, she took that rule out. What she found was that people became more open and honest with her, not less. When someone arrived under the influence, “they’re letting me into their life at this most vulnerable moment.”
She tells the story of one client who came in that way. She made sure he got home safely. A few days later he called and asked her to drive him to treatment, “because you’re the only person I’ve ever seen who allowed me to come in under the influence.” If she had done things the way she was originally trained, she says, “he’d probably be dead.”
It’s the same commitment behind one of CAHRT’s principles: we do not refuse to treat people who are still using.
Abstinence is one option, not the only one
Dee-Dee hasn’t had a drink since 1988, and she’s clear that abstinence works for many people. But harm reduction leaves room for other goals: drinking less often, choosing lower-alcohol drinks, moderating, or stopping altogether. As she puts it, “people use substances and other risky behaviors for reasons,” and understanding those reasons comes before deciding what to change.
She is also honest that moderation doesn’t work for everyone. Many of her clients who try it decide to stop drinking. The difference is that it’s their decision, made with support and without anyone saying “I told you so.” If you’re weighing that choice yourself, our posts on drinking less without quitting and making peace with ambivalence are good places to start. You can also learn more about harm reduction therapy for alcohol.
What moderation actually takes
Dee-Dee describes moderation as a process, not a single decision:
Know where you’re starting. What are you drinking, how much, how often, and in what situations?
Track it. Nobody likes counting drinks, she admits, but apps make it much easier.
Start with the easiest change, not the hardest. “Can you have two glasses of wine instead of three?”
Get curious about why. If you drink to unwind after work before seeing your kids, the goal is to find something that does that job nearly as well.
Get support. Making a change this big is easier with other people. Online groups such as SMART Recovery, LifeRing, HAMS and harm reduction groups let you join from home, even anonymously.
For in-the-moment cravings, see how urge surfing can help.
The relationship matters most
Dee-Dee points to research showing that the relationship between client and clinician accounts for much more of positive change than any specific technique. One of her early bosses liked to say that people don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care. She also notes that when people choose their own path, they tend to be more invested in it.
CAHRT member Perri Franskoviak, PhD, makes a similar case in why harm reduction therapy is just good therapy.
Support for families
When Dee-Dee works with families, the goal isn’t to force a loved one into treatment. It’s to “help you to work on your own anxiety about their risky behavior so that you will feel better,” and to stay connected. If dinner always goes badly, have lunch instead. It’s not everything you want, but it keeps the relationship going.
She also encourages families to plan ahead while things are calm. Ask your loved one: if you drink again, what would you like to have happen, and what should I do?
Where to start reading
Dee-Dee recommended several books for anyone looking at their drinking or supporting someone who is:
How to Change Your Drinking by Kenneth Anderson
Controlling Your Drinking and Listening Well by William R. Miller
Responsible Drinking
Outgrowing Addiction by Stanton Peele
Over the Influence by Patt Denning and Jeannie Little
The 20 Minute Guide for parents and partners, from the Center for Motivation and Change
Curiosity and compassion
Dee-Dee ended the conversation where her work begins: “It really is about curiosity and compassion. Let’s lose the judgmentalness.”
She is one of CAHRT’s founding members, and she describes the network as a group of practitioners who know each other’s work. Learn how CAHRT began, read about how to find a harm reduction therapist, or browse the CAHRT provider directory to find someone who meets you where you are.
You can find more of Dee-Dee’s work, including podcasts and trainings, at deedeestoutconsulting.com.
Dee-Dee Stout appeared on The Kirsten Johnson Podcast in the episode “We’ve Been Treating Addiction Backwards with SUD Expert Dee-Dee Stout.”


Comments