top of page
Search

Outing Myself on My Ambivalence By Dr. Perri Franskoviak https://www.harmreductiontherapy.com/providers/perri-franskoviak

6 days ago
4 min read

Ambivalence is an old friend of mine. Ever since I can remember I have felt at least two, and sometimes more, paradoxical ways about making a commitment, including those I make to myself. Now, this doesn’t mean I’ve lived a life in the shadows. I’ve had long primary relationships and friendships, and work commitments that have spanned more than two decades. Yet always in the background is this tension between freedom to choose on the one side, and on the other a sense of constraint that comes when committing to something. Rarely have I jumped into a training commitment, a graduate school education, or a request to join a board without experiencing ambivalence around the act of choosing. 


There are many reasons why we experience a sense of what I think of as “on the one hand, on the other hand.” For instance, making a choice often comes with the expectation, whether real or not, that we must stick to it. No backing out or changing our minds. Other times it means taking that we might make a choice and be unable to live up to it. Can I really show up for a class I might have agreed to teach and do so with grace and good cheer? What if I cannot live up to the choice I make? Then I’ll feel like a failure. For others, it’s the possibility of upsetting the predictability of the life to which we’ve become accustomed. Why bother. Better the devil I know than the one I don’t. Sometimes it’s the knowledge that comes from making a choice and then having to live with it, which might upset others around us. These may be the folks who will sometimes outsource their freedom to choose to others in their lives. The benefit of this pattern is that when our choice doesn’t pan out, we can then blame others for a choice we wouldn’t have made left on our own. That’s a response I’m particularly fond of when I let others choose for me. Still others can’t bear the loss. I’m not ready to let go of a particular vision of I have of myself in the world. 


Our culture tells us that once we make a choice, we should be able to stick to it. Worse, it brainwashes us into thinking that if we just buy this product, wear this item of clothing, get the promotion we want or the relationship we’ve dreamed of, all of our self-doubts, bad habits, and negative thoughts about ourselves will magically go poof, just like the show I Dream of Jeannie. In a blink of her eyes Jeannie was able to appear and disappear. Just so, we should be able to walk off into the future feeling pleased and happy now that we’ve achieved the change we wanted so desperately for ourselves. Good luck with that.  


The truth is, resolving ambivalence is an illusion. 


This is because every choice, particularly those related to our deepest sense of ourselves, brings with it a kernel of fear. That fear is related to loss, loss of the thing that helps us manage our lives, and most especially the loss of who we think we are, especially if our view of self has been wounded and still bears the scars. It also depends upon how we feel living inside our skin. What do we need to get by, on a day to day and sometimes hour to hour basis? 


I believe all change, including our relationship to what we put into our bodies, occurs when the loss of not changing is greater than the loss of remaining the same. It takes thousands upon thousands of negotiations with the psyche and the body as we move forward, backward, and all around in our process of stepping into change. And never, ever, can we forget our past. We can, however, learn to relate to it differently. For some, that negotiation between past and present may always surface as they learn to accept their ambivalence. Others may be more adept at integrating their new identity into who they are. Neither of these paths and their varied elaborations are mutually exclusive, and nothing is ever wrong with either one of them. In fact, ambivalence is a human experience, something we would do well to remind ourselves of the next time we begin that slide into defeat and shame when our intent to change has not worked out the way we hoped. 


Change takes time, and we don’t need to commit one way or another to resolving our ambivalence. Instead, our work is to learn to live with our complexity. For instance, all things to one side I’d much prefer taking up cigarette smoking again. I love the smell of nicotine and always do my best to position myself in the draft of someone walking ahead of me who’s smoking a cigarette. Who knows, I may pick up again. For now, I accept that I still love smoking and I can also choose not to do so today. And that’s enough for now.   


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


CAHRT Logo-2.png

© 2026 California Association of Harm Reduction Therapists

bottom of page